UnFan: Let's assume it's Rapper American Idol. Let's assume... this is a show. American Idol has some "don't" singers, which nobody should try because those singers are too much for these normal ass people to attempt. Celine Dion, Whitney Houston, Stevie Wonder. Are there rappers that contestants on Rapping American Idol not try? I think if a flow is too fast, it should not be attempted. I don't want to see someone attempt a Mystikal song or a Twista song, when it's so hard to rap so fast and be understood. That's an easy way to get embarrassed/eliminated. But at the same time, nobody should take the easy way out with a Ma$e song or someone with a slow ass flow because that's just lazy.
Jason: A cliche song that no one wants to hear, or thats overheard. Like any thing from Bad Boy circa 93-97. Especially "Mo' Money [Mo' Problems]".
UnFan: So "Juicy" is a do, but "Hypnotize" is a don't?
Jason: Pretty much, any Biggie. Except if it was Biggie. Or something thats completely out of your element. Like if I tried to pull off Tupac, it wouldn't work: 1. I wouldn't feel confident in doing a song that I could not relate to. But thats me personally. 2. I got nothin' for a second point, the first one summed it up. I would try to do a song that fit more of my range, and also do a song of an artist that isn't recognized on a grand scale that I think should. Because I'm on this show for a reason, whomever in charge says I'm good enough to be here. That says something, so if I like something, and you like me, exo facto, you should like said artist.
UnFan: So your big don't is anything outside of their connectivity. Like, a Tribe fan shouldn't do a Eiht song, and vice versa?
Jason: Well, I don't know. I see what you're saying. I guess what I'm trying to say is don't try to do something out of your element, thats a better way of stating it, cause using specific groups/emcees is too vague. Cause in a Tribe song they give a shout out to MC Eiht.
UnFan: True, but that don't mean a Tribe fan listens to Eiht.
Jason: I dont. And its not that I wouldn't, I just havent.
Wednesday, April 11, 2007
Wednesday, April 4, 2007
American Idol
Everybody who breathes knows that there is a such thing as American Idol. It's gotten so big that other countries have their own "Idol" series, such as Indian Idol, Singapore Idol, and New Zealand Idol (to be fair, it started as Pop Idol in England).
However, it is a singing competition, and outside of rappers singing their own hooks, it's conventionally known that rappers aren't singers. This is true in several ways (or, every way), but it's music, right? Why isn't there a show about rappers wanting to be a rapping idol to "music fans" so they can all blindly buy their CDs, even though nobody knows what they sound like considering all they do is cover songs?
Maybe it's because a lot of people think rap isn't music, or that anybody can rap. YouTube is probably the best way to prove the latter wrong, as you can see tons of footage of kids "rapping" without flow, rhythm, or lyrics that would impress even the youngest of toddlers. Sure, maybe anybody can rap, but anybody can also sing. Sure, some people sing off key or whisper-sing, but they're singing, right? The argument that rap isn't music is so faulty that it makes me explode. Rap is one of the few types of music that evolved from a hobby to an art form, and it has everything necessary in music: musical progression, words/lyrics, "singing," melody, you name it, it's got it.
Maybe it's because having a popular vote rapper attempt to gain a career would be... awful. It takes so much to become a rapper, it takes time to beef up your lyrical skills before you can go out and try to prove yourself. It even takes attempts at proving yourself and failing before you can prove yourself with good results. But to have a show where someone could possibly have just enough skill to rap along with their iPod and win because of their charisma or the bad taste a lot of the voting public has is just not a way to prove yourself. Plus, no real rapper wants to rap someone else's song to make themselves heard. They want to do their own thing, which is where real talent lies.
There's also no way millions upon millions of people will watch a show where a bunch of people rap. Shit, I would watch some girl breaking down "Ladies First" or a bunch of people getting' together for an interpretation of "John Blaze". Maybe a complex verse from "Ice Cream" or a real soloist performance of "Eric B. is President." However, how many people who watch American Idol do you think would even know the original rappers behind those songs?
Shit, I'd actually watch that show. Too bad it will never happen. Or maybe we're well off this way. It's easy to be famous through rap nowadays. Mims had a number 1 hit with "This Is Why I'm Hot," and nobody can say that song is doing hip hop any justice. However, if you have a chance, listen to "Niggas Lie a Lot" by Talib Kweli. It's great. Isn't it amazing what a great MC can do with a wack beat?
However, it is a singing competition, and outside of rappers singing their own hooks, it's conventionally known that rappers aren't singers. This is true in several ways (or, every way), but it's music, right? Why isn't there a show about rappers wanting to be a rapping idol to "music fans" so they can all blindly buy their CDs, even though nobody knows what they sound like considering all they do is cover songs?
Maybe it's because a lot of people think rap isn't music, or that anybody can rap. YouTube is probably the best way to prove the latter wrong, as you can see tons of footage of kids "rapping" without flow, rhythm, or lyrics that would impress even the youngest of toddlers. Sure, maybe anybody can rap, but anybody can also sing. Sure, some people sing off key or whisper-sing, but they're singing, right? The argument that rap isn't music is so faulty that it makes me explode. Rap is one of the few types of music that evolved from a hobby to an art form, and it has everything necessary in music: musical progression, words/lyrics, "singing," melody, you name it, it's got it.
Maybe it's because having a popular vote rapper attempt to gain a career would be... awful. It takes so much to become a rapper, it takes time to beef up your lyrical skills before you can go out and try to prove yourself. It even takes attempts at proving yourself and failing before you can prove yourself with good results. But to have a show where someone could possibly have just enough skill to rap along with their iPod and win because of their charisma or the bad taste a lot of the voting public has is just not a way to prove yourself. Plus, no real rapper wants to rap someone else's song to make themselves heard. They want to do their own thing, which is where real talent lies.
There's also no way millions upon millions of people will watch a show where a bunch of people rap. Shit, I would watch some girl breaking down "Ladies First" or a bunch of people getting' together for an interpretation of "John Blaze". Maybe a complex verse from "Ice Cream" or a real soloist performance of "Eric B. is President." However, how many people who watch American Idol do you think would even know the original rappers behind those songs?
Shit, I'd actually watch that show. Too bad it will never happen. Or maybe we're well off this way. It's easy to be famous through rap nowadays. Mims had a number 1 hit with "This Is Why I'm Hot," and nobody can say that song is doing hip hop any justice. However, if you have a chance, listen to "Niggas Lie a Lot" by Talib Kweli. It's great. Isn't it amazing what a great MC can do with a wack beat?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
